Among the two most common messaging points used by those supportive of rapid data center buildout are a) “China is doing it!” and b) it’s your emails and TV streaming that creates their need. And those points are fair but taken out of a far greater context.
First, what many of us are opposed to are the environmental impact on local communities and the proliferation of more fossil fuels (natural gas and oil). By contrast to the US who is making solar and wind installs more difficult, China is building renewables faster than any country in the world right now.
If the US was doing that to power data centers, many including myself would more broadly support their project development. But fossil fuel production that essentially outsources pollution to American communities to enrich the 1% is unacceptable.
If you, like the current administration, use the “China is doing it!” argument then I truly hope you support the installation of renewables. Geothermal in the west, wind on the coast and plains, and solar and storage everywhere for the win. This will happen eventually.
If we can significantly decarbonize data center development and protect air and water standards – something that I and many others think is entirely possible – everyone wins.
The second point about consumer demand driving data center use is somewhat accurate and requires behavioral change (less social, less TV, less dependence on AI, less online shopping, etc.) that Americans will just never do. Collectively, we are a people addicted to the digital life. The only way to hit the big tech elite (Elon, Bezos, Ellison, Zuck, whatever owns TikTok, Altman, etc.) is not to use them – and that is very unlikely to happen.
However, no one individual is the reason we need a data center. It’s a drop in the ocean. The many social media commenters blaming Bill or Jen for a data center because they stream Seinfeld (who doesn’t?) is quite the stretch.
Major corporations owned by very rich people are using AI for everything on a greater scale, eliminating jobs and requiring tremendous amounts of power from the grid. This is the principal reason why data center buildout is such a fixation as of this writing.
Am I opposed to data centers? No. I’m a capitalist who believes tech advancement is generally for the good of people everywhere. But I am very opposed to enriching the ridiculously wealthy at the expense of our community health and well-being, which is exactly what I expect will happen if we continue down this path.
Editors note: Shortly after this was published, Heatmap News reported Data Center Cancellations Top $260 Billion in 2026.




